In a rare departure from their usual dynamic, Whoopi Goldberg and Sunny Hostin actually disagreed during a segment on The View.

Decider reports that the argument occurred over a conversation about Rebel Wilson’s weight loss. Wilson recently talked about how her producers didn’t want her to lose weight for fear that her film roles would decrease. Hostin said that Wilson and other actors shouldn’t have to worry about their weight when it comes to their careers. But she she eventually ran into a snag when she voiced her opinion about singers.

“I do think, sometimes, when there’s a singer that loses weight, sometimes they lose their voice,” she said, leading Goldberg to vehemently say, “That’s not true.”