Former president Donald Trump and his allies have long used racist tropes, anti-immigrant fears and other offensive tactics to drum up support from their base while antagonizing those targeted by this rhetoric. But Trump’s Sunday rally at New York City’s Madison Square Garden took the campaign to new lows for racial dog whistling and outright bigoted comments, living up to the label of ‘Nazi rally’ that had been placed on the event.
Fallout from comedian’s Puerto Rico insult and Dr. Phil’s DEI comment
Even before Sunday’s events, Trump has been increasingly criticized for his racist and fascist language, and many compared his rally to a 1939 event by the American Nazi Party held at Madison Square Garden in 1939. For many, the Trump event lived up to the troubling hype with a slew of racism and conspiracy theories being touted by the former president and his guests. Perhaps the most notorious moment of the event came when conservative comedian Tony Hinchcliffe, who spewed several offensive “jokes” about Black people, Latinos, Palestinians and Jewish people, insulted Puerto Rico as a “floating island of garbage.” The remark drew intense backlash across social media and spurred a number of Puerto Rican pop stars like Jennifer Lopez, Bad Bunny and Ricky Martin to throw their support behind Kamala Harris.
Dr. Phil drew criticism for his remarks, including his comments that “this country was built on hard work … Not on DEI.”
Dr. Phil: This country was built on hard work.. Not on DEI pic.twitter.com/QngDJKbDnc
— Acyn (@Acyn) October 27, 2024
The NAACP pointed out in a tweet that the “hard work” that built the United States was “on the backs of Black, Brown, and Immigrants from all across this WORLD,” many of whom were enslaved.
This country was absolutely built on hard work Dr. Phil…on the backs of Black, Brown, and lmmigrants from all across this WORLD! Many of which who were forced to do so!
SLAVERY.
Let us know when you’re ready to tell the WHOLE story. https://t.co/DbagsQFIFd
— NAACP (@NAACP) October 27, 2024
Others pointed out that he owes his success to the support that Oprah gave him.
Dr. Phil was Oprah’s DEI hire. I’m sure there were more credible psychologists or whatever he is that she could have elevated.
— Island Girl – 100% Pro-Choice, Vote Blue (@bluepolitics_) October 27, 2024
Trump and others trot out insults and conspiracy theories
Businessman and celebrity Grant Cardone referred to Harris as having “pimp handlers” and told the audience that “we need to slaughter these other people,” referring to Democrats.
Grant Cardone calls Mark Cuban a "simp" and says Kamala Harris has "pimp handlers." He then says of Democrats "we need to slaughter these other people" pic.twitter.com/TQu5vKwydF
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) October 27, 2024
David Rem referred to Harris as “the devil” and “the anti-Christ.”
"She is the devil. She is the antichrist." pic.twitter.com/fX9NaXFOvd
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) October 27, 2024
When Trump finally took the stage, he trotted out various conspiracy theories and race-baiting accusations from the past, such as claiming that prisoners from Congo were pouring into the United States and that immigrants had overtaken Times Square in New York City. He also pointed toward the 1790s — an era where slavery was still legal in the United States — as an era of “law and order.”
Trump on America in the 1790s, when slavery was legal: "That's when they had law and order."
He then addresses Speaker Johnson and says, "get ready" pic.twitter.com/1sEPASX7bU
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) October 27, 2024
Overall, the rally painted a picture of a Trump campaign eager to appeal to the worst aspects of its supporters by demonizing Harris and people of color. The backlash to the event has been severe, and the next week will demonstrate whether or not this event ends up shifting voters as they decide who will be the next president of the United States.