A Twitter thread posted by user @Whitleysdaughtr gained traction for sharing throwback photos of female stars labeled “thick” in the ’90s and early 2000s.
The photos served as a brutal reminder of just how toxic those times were and how body image differs from our perceptions today. So much so that Gen Z had a hard time believing it.
The first photo was of star LisaRaye McCoy with the caption: “Another reminder of the women we considered ‘thick’ in the 2000s.”
Another reminder of the women we considered “thick” in the 2000s. pic.twitter.com/LEGWLSmWPT
— Whitley (@Whitleysdaughtr) May 10, 2023
Another tweet added a photo of Jennifer Lopez, who was placed in the same category. It isn’t hard to see why Gen Z would be shocked by this assertion: JLo, known as “thick” for her butt in the ‘00s, would be considered tiny by 2023 standards.
JLo had people going crazy over what would be considered a teaspoon of ass these days😂 The standards of thick have definitely evolved. pic.twitter.com/Oap2rzRe8v
— Whitley (@Whitleysdaughtr) May 11, 2023
Other examples in the thread included Kim Kardashian, who left many in awe at the time for being a “thick” white woman.
Kim Kardashian in early 2000s when she became popular because everyone was in awe of a “thick,” White woman😂 pic.twitter.com/rTHbI3TQOf
— Whitley (@Whitleysdaughtr) May 11, 2023
Jordin Sparks and Raven Symone, who were considered too “fat” to just be “thick” at the time, were also added to the discussion. In fact, when Sparks lost weight back in 2012, many praised her — with one article even saying she had “always been a chunky girl.”
Jordan Sparks is a perfect example of a person who was considered fat during that time. When her and Raven Symone loss weight many people, yes even Black, cheered! Mediatakeout was one of the sites that made it a huge deal. pic.twitter.com/qm4PsvttaY
— Whitley (@Whitleysdaughtr) May 11, 2023
The photos shared seemed so outlandish, Gen Z could not fathom that the celebrity women in question were really called “big” in that era. One even leveled the accusation that: “Y’all just be making sh** up for real.”
Y’all just be making shit up fr 😭 https://t.co/aVVEW7BEYA
— Niyah (@niyahgetspaid) May 10, 2023
Millennial Twitter users were quick to clap back, with one pointing out, “[I don’t know] why [people] saying you lying just [because] they have no recollection/weren’t even born lol.”
Idk why ppl saying you lying just bcus they have no recollection/weren’t even born lol.
Look at how they were referencing bodies like Buffie the Body in this clip because a lot of women weren’t even proud of being thick like her & she actually looks good, so what does that say.. pic.twitter.com/BiZXkhTa65
— LAUREN LO (@1auren1o) May 11, 2023
Twitter user @Whitleysdaughtr noted it must be difficult to imagine that kind of culture through a 2023 lens, which is why many Gen Z “can acknowledge that skinny was very much in, but can’t believe slimmer women with bigger butts and breast were considered thick.”
They’re looking at it from 2023 lenses and don’t remember the past. They can acknowledge that skinny was very much in, but can’t believe slimmer women with bigger butts and breast were considered thick.
— Whitley (@Whitleysdaughtr) May 11, 2023
With Twitter users of both generations up in arms, body positivity advocate Lizzo weighed in.
In a since-viral TikTok, the “About Damn Time” singer got candid about body image, discussing how discourse around “thick” bodies has changed over the last two decades.
The nearly three-minute video sets the record straight for younger social media users about the evolution of beauty standards.
@lizzo FUN FACT: EVERYBODY IS A BODY✨
After a brief explanation of the thread, Lizzo acknowledged the disbelief coating some of the comments.
“There are people who are like, ‘You just be saying anything. This isn’t true. This isn’t thick.’ And it’s important to note that a lot of these people were not born yet. Or they were babies in this era,” Lizzo explained.
Lizzo added that she did not post the TikTok to “convince” people of what was “considered unhealthy in the early 2000s.” Instead, she noted that she was simply there to “remark on how quickly the conversation in culture can change.”
Several commented on their own experiences navigating the toxic culture of that era and how it affected them.
“I have serious body [dysmorphia] from growing up in this time and being a teen. The standards were so toxic,” a user commented.
“It permanently caused body issues for all of us who grew up seeing that. I don’t remember ever loving my body. It’s so sad,” another millennial said, reflecting on the era.
As a pioneer of the body-positive movement, the Grammy-award-winning artist said watching it evolve has been “humbling” and an “honor.” In true Lizzo fashion, she ended her TikTok with a powerful message reminding viewers of their inherent worth.
“So, if you feel like the outlier, or if you feel like you’re not like everybody else, keep being yourself and watch the world catch up with you,” she said.
TikTok viewers praised Lizzo for speaking out, thanking the musician for her candor.
“Lizzo, if I had had you as an example as a young girl, my whole self-perception would have turned out so much better. I am thankful for you,” one viewer wrote.
“FUN FACT: EVERYBODY IS A BODY,” Lizzo wrote in the caption of the clip.